Will The Real Darren McFadden Please Stand Up?

Sep 23, 2013; Denver, CO, USA; Oakland Raiders running back Darren McFadden (20) runs with the ball during the second half against the Denver Broncos at Sports Authority Field at Mile High. The Broncos won 37-21. Mandatory Credit: Chris Humphreys-USA TODAY Sports

We assumed the story of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde was a myth, but apparently the soul inhabits our world as Darren McFadden.

McFadden doesn’t seem to have a split personality, until you see him in an NFL stadium. Under the circumstance, his character becomes unpredictable.

We know the McFadden we’ve grown to love, the running back with size and 4.33 speed who purposely lowers his shoulders and keeps churning his wheels for extra yards. The same person who can turn a pass in the flats (or his own throw) into a lengthy gain and keep defenses on their heels.

But we must acknowledge the darker, sadder side of McFadden, the individual who runs nonchalantly between the tackles and recovers from injuries at the pace of a 50-year old. He can be found on the sidelines nursing his latest bruise while dreaming of the next big multi-year deal that may never come.

McFadden’s environment hasn’t helped matters (he’s had a poor supporting cast since entering the league in 2008), but we thought his nice side was back for good when he rushed for 129 yards in Week 2. Then his ugly alter-ego reared its head, and (surprise, surprise) the back is out indefinitely with a strained hamstring.

McFadden is in the last year of his rookie contract, so his performance the rest of the season will strongly dictate his NFL future. The erratic rusher isn’t in a position of leverage negotiation-wise, but the Oakland Raiders still have a tough choice to make.

Should the team cut their losses and trade McFadden at his lowest value before the October 29 deadline?

Or should the Raiders bet on All-Pro potential and commit to the running back at a discount price in the offseason, only to risk him walking away?

The head-scratching case of McFadden is just another question general manager Reggie McKenzie must mull. But if the former Arkansas star can’t shake his gridiron disorder, the decision will be easier.

Topics: Darren McFadden, NFL, Oakland Raiders, Reggie McKenzie

Want more from Golden Gate Sports?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • Bob

    Just let him go and pick up a more durable RB next year. Never should have let Bush go. I know, I know, cap space.

    • http://theruination.net/ Rui Thomas

      Bush was underrated. I feel like the 49ers are hoping Lattimore is their own version.

    • Ricardo Montalban

      I hate sayin this but we should have got rid of McFadden and kept Bush…go Raiders!!!!

  • Tim Martindale

    Have to say I’ve given up on him

  • KloverJane

    it’s really getting old. what’s with the up the middle play when they’re healthy? That fails almost every time….

  • Pingback: Will the Real Darren McFadden Please Stand Up?The Ruination